What are the Similarities and Differences Between Edexcel and Cambridge? Which is the Best?
If we talk of international education, Edexcel and Cambridge Assessment International Education would be two popular examination boards. Both have international qualifications but these are two different boards. This paper will focus on the comparisons between the two: Edexcel and Cambridge: their curriculum structure, method of assessment, algorithm of the grading process, endorsement around the world and many more and see which might be prudent to consider.
Steps
1. Curriculum Structure Part
Edexcel:
- Provides schools and students with other alternatives as regards the topic selection by being less rigid with the curriculum.
- Divided into levels, the curriculum takes the format of modules such that each level is assessed on a comparatively smaller unit.
- Such a framework permits one or two modules if required to be retaken meaning a number of chances to do better on the module grading system.
Cambridge:
- Presents a more straightforward curriculum in which the subjects are thought out chronologically.
- In general, the curriculum is factored in comprehensively to ensure that there is adequate mastery of topics taught.
- The assessment at the end includes all the taught areas; hence this can be more difficult for students since it covers a longer span of knowledge retention.
2. Assessment Methods
Edexcel:
- Assesses students by using a mixture of classwork and examinations.
- The modularity of the curriculum also means that students do not have to take all the assessments in one go.
- It is common for a moderate amount of coursework to be incorporated into the final grade, which is advantageous to learners taking such coursework throughout the length of the course.
This picture for representative purpose. Picture courtesy: pearson.com
Cambridge:
- Makes use mainly of final exams in assessing learners.
- The Cambridge examinations are quite severe in that they assess not only knowledge, but also knowledge application, problem-solving ability and critical thinking skills.
- Although some subjects may include some coursework, the course work got from most of the unit is what one takes at the end of the course which can be worse in terms of effort and experience.
This picture for representative purpose. Picture courtesy: myschoolz.com
3. Assessment Systems
Edexcel:
- For Edexcel's GCSEs, the grading system is A+ - G and for the A-Levels, it is A+ - E, A - E
- Thus, the grading is more done, concisely allowing the students to attain grades in any of the modules, a factor that is good for students targeting some performance aspects.
- By virtue of the use of the modular system, the students are able to comprehend their performance in terms of grades all through the duration of the course, a condition that aids the students in the management of their study strategies.
Cambridge:
- Cambridge, IGCSE's and A level grading systems, also span the ranges of A*-G for IGCSEE's and A*-E for A level respectively.
- In as much as there are assessments in between, more often than not, the students' grades are based on the final examinations.
- Even if this kind of grading is mostly viewed as a clinical traditionalist perspective, where a grade is to be given without many other details on the student - achievement was an overall measure on one single final.
This picture for representative purpose. Picture courtesy: slideplayer.com
4. Global Recognition and University Acceptance
Edexcel:
- Edexcel standard qualifications are accepted by universities all over the globe, especially in the UK, USA and Canada.
- A lot of flexibility with regards to subjects and means of assessment is viewed as a positive attribute, which is why a lot of students like Edexcel qualifications.
- Certain schools might favour Edexcel qualifications for learners who perform steadily right through modular examinations.
Cambridge:
- With regard to academic achievement, a Cambridge qualification is one that is recognized and respected around the world.
- It is often the case that very high-ranking universities prefer a linear curriculum and difficult examinations.
- Cambridge students usually exhibit a strong grasp of their subjects and this can help them a great deal during their university application process.
5. Teaching and Learning Approach
Edexcel:
- Provides for an individualistic approach to learning, this is possible with the modular system since the students can zoom in on various interests.
- There is a discretion among teachers to adjust the content to be relevant to the child therefore making the content being learned attractive.
- Students are improved on time management matters, self -organisation and self directed study because of the primary stress that is put on continuous assessment.
Cambridge:
- Discriminates with a more conventional style that places more emphasis and time on course content delivery.
- Being performance based where students write their final exams after learning everything in the course makes students good at remembering things, critical and creative thought and recalling facts over a long period of time.
- However, Cambridge is considered to be somewhat more difficult, but this contributes to greater comprehension of the subject content than what would otherwise be the case.
6. Subject Availability and Breadth
Edexcel:
- Has an extensive subject offering especially at the level of GCSE to enable students to diversify in their interests.
- The modular structure makes it relatively easier for students to combine subjects minus the barriers of combining subjects inside irrelevant areas and subjects and future dispositions.
Cambridge:
- Like Edexcel, the curriculum involves both advanced and co-curriculum offerings but leaning towards the more conventional studies.
- The curriculum is quite allowable as it is not restricted to any one field and has interesting offerings in sciences, humanities, languages as well as the arts.
- Apart from the conventional subjects, Cambridge also provides innovative courses like the above subject which makes pupils think on global topics.
7. Examination Difficulty
Edexcel:
- Recognition follows that such a system tends to be relatively more learner-friendly as there is more of progressive achievement through constant assessments.
- Due to the behaviour of the modular exams covering smaller chunks at a time, there is less pressure on the learners as they do not have to grasp a lot at once.
- If the students feel that they will be able to be better off if their evaluations are consistent in terms of even a minor aspect of their studies, then this strategy would suit them.
Cambridge:
- Generally associated with sophisticated examinations, which normally demand that the learner comprehends information and accurately implements it in new scenarios.
- The finals engage all the areas learned since the beginning of the course and that could be very tough at the same time very advantageous to the learners who perform their best when time pressure is high.
- Cambridge's level of difficulty is seen to condition students towards the next level with most cases being witnessed in most of them being in the advanced placement.
8. Support and Resources
Edexcel:
- First, it supplies plenty of resources such as textbooks, online support and teacher support.
- Everybody knows that using past papers and modular evaluations is a great help to students and teachers in charge of exam preparation.
- Edexcel furthermore has a timetable for teacher training as a means to enhance the teachers' method of teaching the curriculum.
Cambridge:
- Such tasks can be supported by additional materials such as plenty of textbooks, e-learning and teaching aids.
- Support of the above nature to the teachers includes teacher training and orientation programs on curriculum implementation.
- A bigger percentage of teachers in comparison to other resources prefer that of Cambridge resources. This is especially in those that consider balancing gripping analytical thought with various comprehension skill activities.
9. Flexibility and Adaptability
Edexcel:
- Particularly known with regards to the modular assessment and range of subjects, it gives students a number of options.
- And for students with different educational skills or those with a need for a specific type of education, this applies to them as well.
- There is however, the danger of getting assertive admitting that the flexibility that the edexcel curriculum allows fosters the move towards student- centred learning approaches in the educational institutions.
Cambridge:
- Cambridge has a rather rigid curriculum in comparison with Edexcel, especially when it comes to the variety of assessments.
- The linear approach thus puts the learners in a position to adopt the conventional style of learning which may not be suitable for all.
- But on the other hand the structure of the Cambridge system can offer a more uniform and stable experience which is liked by some students and teachers.
10. Which One is Better?
Edexcel:
- Easier for the learners who prefer to be tested on a regular basis and have a flexible learning program.
- Most suitable for those students who prefer to handle targeted subjects or those individuals that may require extra time to perform well in class.
- Ideal for learners who perform well in environments that don't require much pressure and they receive constant feedback.
Cambridge:
- Suitable for the students who perform well in the tests and exams which are more exhaustive and who find challenge in difficulty.
- Good for those that intend to be in the top universities, especially in the UK and Europe where Cambridge University is prestigious.
- Accommodating for the learners who are organised, good time managers and those who are willing to apply the knowledge several years after the exams.